ArticlesThe Dark Room

Escaping the Scapegoat Role

By Dr. Johnathan Hines, DCC • Dr. Hines Inc.

You were selected. Not randomly. Not fairly. Deliberately. The family system needed someone to carry its dysfunction, and it picked you. Not because you were the weakest. Because you were the strongest. Strong enough to absorb the blame, tolerate the isolation, and keep going.

How Scapegoats Get Selected

The scapegoat is usually the child who sees the most. The one who asks uncomfortable questions. The one who won't pretend. In a system built on illusion, the person who sees reality becomes a threat. So the system assigns them a role: the problem child, the difficult one, the one who causes all the trouble.

Once assigned, the role becomes self-reinforcing. Everything you do gets filtered through the narrative. If you succeed, it's dismissed or attributed to luck. If you fail, it's proof of what they always said about you. The role becomes a lens the entire family uses to interpret your behavior.

What It Costs

Scapegoats carry chronic shame. Not the healthy kind that says "I did something wrong." The toxic kind that says "I am something wrong." You walk through life feeling fundamentally defective, always one mistake away from confirming what your family told you.

Scapegoats become hyperperformers. If the system says you're not enough, you'll prove them wrong by being the best. Best at work. Best in the gym. Best at everything measurable. But the performance never fills the hole, because the hole was dug by people who were never going to be satisfied.

Scapegoats attract narcissists. You were trained to tolerate dysfunction, so dysfunction feels normal. The spouse who criticizes everything you do feels familiar. The boss who takes credit for your work feels like home. You keep recreating the system because it's the only relational template your brain has.

How to Get Out

The exit starts with one sentence: "This was never about me." The role was about the system's needs, not your deficiencies. You weren't scapegoated because of who you are. You were scapegoated because of what the system required. When you separate your identity from the role, the role loses its power.

Then comes the hard part: grief. You have to grieve the family you deserved but didn't get. The parent who should have protected you. The sibling who should have stood with you. The childhood that was stolen. This grief is not weakness. It's the doorway out.

After grief comes rebuilding. New identity. New boundaries. New relationships built on truth instead of performance. This is Phase 2 of The Lion Protocol: naming the wound, mapping the system, and building an identity that belongs to you instead of the family that assigned one.

Ready?

The Lion Protocol is for men who are done hiding. 12 sessions. 6 months. Everything changes.

Apply for The Lion Protocol

Or take the free Dark Room Assessment first →